The Idea Factory
№ 283Friday, 6 November 2026

Social Proof Isn't The Same Anymore

About 10 years ago, testimonials were front and centre in the fitness marketing playbook

Before and afters, client quotes, results posts - all of it.

As with the mass adoption of anything, this is round about the time that it broke.

Mostly, it broke because it resolved the wrong uncertainty.

A testimonial answers ‘Does this work?’

Back then - online coaching was kinda new, and so it probably worked to an extent because people weren’t sure if they could get a result without an in person PT.

That’s not the case anymore.

Now people want to know,

‘Will this work for me and how bad will it feel before it’s working?’

It’s personal, it’s about the process - and it’s something that someone else’s results can’t really answer.

If you think about the maturation and sophistication of the market - they’ve seen dozens of testimonials at this point

And it’s naive to assume that people aren’t already generating their own with AI - so they lose any inherent value they might have had.

Testimonials can become another entry in the evidence pile that says ‘This doesn’t work for people like me’

I actually would go as far as to say that the format that previously did build trust, now confirms the doubt that people have - doubt it’s meant to remove.

What we need to do instead? Speak to the uncertainty at the level it lives.

And tell better stories.

A story models the process in a way that a before and after with a caption simply can’t.

It models the mess in the middle, giving the prospect something to match their own uncertainty against.

It’s no longer enough to post ‘I’m great get great results look at Deborah she did great you’ll do great come and work with me it’s great’ type stuff

It needs to be deeper, more thought out and more reflective of the journey itself

Which I think is a good thing - any change in the market that gives an advantage to the coach who works harder and thinks deeper?

Should feel like a win to you

Charlie Beestone · My Idea Factory
ArchiveRSS
© 2026 Charlie Beestone · The Idea Factory